Should the US govt bail out the American Auto Giants?
-
Have you ever talked to a pipe fitter Dave...seriously? They thread pipe and screw it together...not rocket science. Now the designers of sprinklers on the other hand...they do some serious thinking/calculating.
-
Ehh...nobody really does much thinking anymore because computers are pretty much able to do all that for you...
For instance, a computer can figure out what the pressure at any point in a pneumatic system will be given certain conditions/intputs/outputs. It can figure out voltages anywhere in a circuit based on desired input/output voltages. It doesn't take much skill to figure that out.
Sure there are certain instances where human ingenuity can help as far as tweaking certain system parts to sacrifice something here to make large gains there...but...overall computers can do it all.
-
StangerBanger96;246984 wrote:
Ehh...nobody really does much thinking anymore because computers are pretty much able to do all that for you...For instance, a computer can figure out what the pressure at any point in a pneumatic system will be given certain conditions/intputs/outputs. It can figure out voltages anywhere in a circuit based on desired input/output voltages. It doesn't take much skill to figure that out.
At present, there are no programs out that will calculate properly for a foam system. There are no programs out that will autocalculate device counts for detection within a given room. There are none that will place sprinkler heads automatically. There are no programs that will autoconfigure a room to meet NFPA/NEC/IBC/IFC standards. If there were, I would own the damn thing already. You are involved in this industry Dustin, you should know as well as anyone the amount of time that goes into design/cad/engineering/bidding.
-
zbrown;246986 wrote:
Starting at any position out here on the rigs is 26+/hr..... whether it be driving a water truck or just being someones bitch.....no skill required, just need the want to work
My point exactly.
-
tjamz;246997 wrote:
At present, there are no programs out that will calculate properly for a foam system. There are no programs out that will autocalculate device counts for detection within a given room. There are none that will place sprinkler heads automatically. There are no programs that will autoconfigure a room to meet NFPA/NEC/IBC/IFC standards. If there were, I would own the damn thing already. You are involved in this industry Dustin, you should know as well as anyone the amount of time that goes into design/cad/engineering/bidding.Not to mention, you toss an AHJ into the mess...
-
MisterCMK;247000 wrote:
Not to mention, you toss an AHJ into the mess...No doubt...there is no function of any program that has the ability to educate an AHJ about the errors of his ways.
-
tjamz;246977 wrote:
Have you ever talked to a pipe fitter Dave...seriously? They thread pipe and screw it together...not rocket science. Now the designers of sprinklers on the other hand...they do some serious thinking/calculating.LOL, yeah i've heard that about those sprinkler designers....
I have a good friend who is a pipe fitter, he does mostly mechanical systems and some of the stuff I've seen him do is pure artwork. Sure it's not brainwork like a sprinkler designer, :drunken_smilie: but it is a fairly highly skilled profession IMO.
DaveH
'94 Supra- 7.77 @ 176mph -
tjamz;246997 wrote:
At present, there are no programs out that will calculate properly for a foam system. There are no programs out that will autocalculate device counts for detection within a given room. There are none that will place sprinkler heads automatically. There are no programs that will autoconfigure a room to meet NFPA/NEC/IBC/IFC standards. If there were, I would own the damn thing already. You are involved in this industry Dustin, you should know as well as anyone the amount of time that goes into design/cad/engineering/bidding.I guess my point more was to say...there are a lot of jobs people think are highly skilled that in fact are completed 90% by computers. I know there are various aspects of engineering and designing that absolutley require human ingenuity, but, there are also a lot of things that even ten years ago required a lot of thought and now only require 3 clicks of a mouse.
Give it ten years and that program you're wanting will be out
-
StangerBanger96;247028 wrote:
I guess my point more was to say...there are a lot of jobs people think are highly skilled that in fact are completed 90% by computers. I know there are various aspects of engineering and designing that absolutley require human ingenuity, but, there are also a lot of things that even ten years ago required a lot of thought and now only require 3 clicks of a mouse.Give it ten years and that program you're wanting will be out
I've been working on implementing something like what I described as a plug-in for auto-cad for a couple of years already....there's just too many variables when it comes to stuff like that. It would be nice though, then those damn engineers would finally put a system together properly.
-
sounds like a good market opportunity for a competant programmer.
what makes doing automatic sprinkler layout difficult? can code compliance be measured objectively? if so, would a dimensioned drawing contain enough information to verify code compliance? If a proposed layout meets all of the appropriate codes, is it a suffient layout? why or why not ?
i don't understand why the problem would be intractible to do in software. can you help explain it?
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login